DoggieLawn XL Real Grass Puppy Pee Pad (24 x 48 in) vs HQ4US 4LEGS Large Artificial Grass Pad with Tray (34 x 23 in)
Side by side on every dimension we score, so you can judge which suits your dog.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, PawBench earns from qualifying purchases. Prices shown are approximate and subject to change. Always verify current pricing on Amazon before purchasing.
DoggieLawn XL Real Grass Puppy Pee Pad (24 x 48 in)
$44.85 · ★ 4.2 (386)
vs
HQ4US 4LEGS Large Artificial Grass Pad with Tray (34 x 23 in)
$69.99 · ★ 4.2 (646)
66
Effectiveness
66
66
Ease of Use
66
66
Versatility
66
74
Value
74
61
Owner Satisfaction
68
Differences only
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Buy | ||
PawBench Scoremethodology → | Effectiveness 66 Ease of Use 66 Versatility 66 Value 74 Owner Satisfaction 61 | Effectiveness 66 Ease of Use 66 Versatility 66 Value 74 Owner Satisfaction 68 |
| Buyer sentiment | Quality Functionality Suitability For Apartments Durability Odor Buyers praise quality, functionality and suitability for apartments. Mixed feedback on value for money and grass quality. Some flag durability and odor. Based on 294 user mentions | Functionality Sanitary Size Included Accessories Durability Buyers praise functionality, sanitary, size and included accessories. Mixed feedback on value for money and odor reduction. Some flag durability. Based on 192 user mentions |
| Size | 24 x 48 inches (XL) | 34 x 23 inches (Large) |
| Material | Real grass on a disposable base | — |
| Best For | Medium dogs; apartments and balconies | Dogs under 28 inches nose-to-tail (Beagle, Shiba Inu size) |
| Disposal | Trash or green compost bin | — |
| Included | — | 2 turf mats, drainage grate, plastic tray |
| Cleaning | — | Machine-washable turf; rinse tray with water |
* Prices are approximate and may vary. Please check the latest price on Amazon.
What owners actually say
DoggieLawn XL Real Grass Puppy Pee Pad (24 x 48 in)
66/100 sentiment
N=294
+ Quality+ Functionality+ Suitability For Apartments± Value for money± Grass Quality± Color− Durability− Odor
HQ4US 4LEGS Large Artificial Grass Pad with Tray (34 x 23 in)
77/100 sentiment
N=192
+ Functionality+ Sanitary+ Size+ Included Accessories± Value for money± Odor Reduction± Grass Quality− Durability
Pros & cons
DoggieLawn XL Real Grass Puppy Pee Pad (24 x 48 in)
Pros
- ✓Real grass in a 24 x 48 in pad — big enough for medium dogs
- ✓Disposable or compostable; no cleaning between changes
- ✓Grass texture that outdoor-trained dogs accept quickly
Cons
- ✗Lifespan and odor are mixed in owner feedback once the grass wilts
- ✗Recurring purchase, not a one-time buy
HQ4US 4LEGS Large Artificial Grass Pad with Tray (34 x 23 in)
Pros
- ✓Two turf mats included so one can dry while the other is in use
- ✓Grate keeps the turf above the collected urine; tray rinses clean
- ✓No recurring cost after purchase
Cons
- ✗Needs regular rinsing or odor builds fast — a real chore
- ✗Turf durability is mixed in owner feedback