Merrick Grain-Free Real Texas Beef vs Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Chicken
Head-to-head comparison — specs, scores, pros & cons, and our expert verdict to help you pick the right one for your dog.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, PawBench earns from qualifying purchases. Prices shown are approximate and subject to change. Always verify current pricing on Amazon before purchasing.
Merrick Grain-Free Real Texas Beef
From $35.88(prices may vary)
📦 Buy on Amazon
Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Chicken
From $32.28(prices may vary)
📦 Buy on AmazonRatings Breakdown
| Category | Merrick Grain-Free Real Texas Beef | Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Chicken |
|---|---|---|
| Overall | 9.2 | 9 |
| Value | 8.4 | 8.5 |
| Quality | 9.3 | 9.2 |
| Durability | 8.8 | 8.6 |
| Ease of Use | 8.9 | 8.7 |
Pros & Cons
Merrick Grain-Free Real Texas Beef
Pros
- ✓Chunky beef stew with visible vegetables
- ✓Grain-free with zero artificial preservatives
- ✓Deboned beef is the first ingredient
- ✓Excellent palatability even for picky eaters
- ✓Cans are BPA-free
Cons
- ✗Higher sodium than some competing wet foods
- ✗Price per can is steep for large-breed owners
Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Chicken
Pros
- ✓Real chicken with garden vegetables and brown rice
- ✓Balanced enough to use as a complete meal
- ✓No poultry by-product meals
- ✓Smooth pâté-meets-chunky texture most dogs prefer
- ✓One of the most affordable premium wet foods
Cons
- ✗Contains carrageenan, which some owners avoid
- ✗Occasional inconsistency in texture between batches
Specs Comparison
| Spec | Merrick Grain-Free Real Texas Beef | Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Chicken |
|---|---|---|
| Pack Size | 12 cans (12.7 oz each) | 12 cans (12.5 oz each) |
| Protein Source | Deboned Beef | Chicken |
| Life Stage | Adult | Adult |
| Grain-Free | Yes | No (includes brown rice) |
| Special Feature | Chunky stew texture with visible vegetables | Garden vegetables, balanced as stand-alone meal |
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Buy | ||
PawBench Scoremethodology → | Nutrition 77 Ingredients 89 Palatability 80 Value 87 Owner Satisfaction 76 | Nutrition 81 Ingredients 75 Palatability 72 Value 87 Owner Satisfaction 71 |
| Buyer sentiment | Quality Ingredients Taste Health Value for money Odor Buyers praise quality, ingredients, taste and health. Mixed feedback on digestion and digestibility. Some flag value for money and odor. Based on 217 user mentions | Quality Ingredients Nutrition Digestive Effects Odor Buyers praise quality, ingredients and nutrition. Mixed feedback on value for money and taste. Some flag digestive effects and odor. Based on 114 user mentions |
| Pack Size | 12 cans (12.7 oz each) | 12 cans (12.5 oz each) |
| Protein Source | Deboned Beef | Chicken |
| Life Stage | Adult | Adult |
| Grain-Free | Yes | No (includes brown rice) |
| Special Feature | Chunky stew texture with visible vegetables | Garden vegetables, balanced as stand-alone meal |
* Prices are approximate and may vary. Please check the latest price on Amazon.
Our Verdict
Winner
Merrick Grain-Free Real Texas Beef
9.2/10 overall
It's extremely close, but Merrick Grain-Free Real Texas Beef edges ahead with a slightly higher overall score (9.2 vs 9). Both are excellent choices — you really can't go wrong with either. Pick the one that best fits your dog's specific needs and your budget.
From $35.88 (prices may vary)
📦 Buy Merrick Grain-Free Real Texas Beef on Amazon