Whimzees Variety Pack Dental Chews (Small, 56 ct) vs Best Bully Sticks 6" Bully Sticks (25 ct)
Scored head-to-head on every dimension — with a clear verdict and the best price on each.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, PawBench earns from qualifying purchases. Prices shown are approximate and subject to change. Always verify current pricing on Amazon before purchasing.
Our verdict: Whimzees Variety Pack Dental Chews (Small, 56 ct) is the clear winner, 76 to 60 on the PawBench Score. The gap shows across most dimensions — especially vohc seal of acceptance for plaque and tartar. Choose Best Bully Sticks 6" Bully Sticks (25 ct) only if a specific feature it has is a dealbreaker.
| Spec | ||
|---|---|---|
| Buy | ||
PawBench Scoremethodology → | Quality 74 Ease of Use 74 Versatility 74 Value 77 Owner Satisfaction 80 | Quality 62 Ease of Use 62 Versatility 62 Value 60 Owner Satisfaction 56 |
| Buyer sentiment | Dental Health Pet pleasure Freshness Enjoyment Texture Buyers praise dental health, pet pleasure, freshness and enjoyment. Mixed feedback on value for money and digestibility. Some flag texture. Based on 481 user mentions | Quality Pet pleasure Chewability Odor Thickness Buyers praise quality, pet pleasure and chewability. Mixed feedback on value for money and durability. Some flag odor and thickness. Based on 6,496 user mentions |
| Size | Small (15–25 lb dogs), 56 count | 6 inches, 25 count |
| VOHC Seal | Yes — plaque & tartar | — |
| Protein Source | Plant-based (no meat) | — |
| Grain-Free | Yes | — |
| Feeding | 1 chew per day | — |
| Calories per Stick | — | ~80 |
| Ingredient | — | 100% beef pizzle (single ingredient) |
| Sourcing | — | USA grass-fed beef |
| Rawhide | — | No |
* Prices are approximate and may vary. Please check the latest price on Amazon.
What owners actually say
Pros & cons
Whimzees Variety Pack Dental Chews (Small, 56 ct)
Pros
- ✓VOHC Seal of Acceptance for plaque and tartar
- ✓Plant-based, grain-free — useful for dogs with poultry sensitivities
- ✓Six shapes (toothbrush, stix, alligator, etc.) keep dogs engaged longer than a single shape
Cons
- ✗Plant-based texture is softer than Greenies — not ideal for very aggressive chewers who gulp
- ✗Variety pack mixes shapes — some dogs reject one specific shape
Best Bully Sticks 6" Bully Sticks (25 ct)
Pros
- ✓Single-ingredient 100% beef pizzle — transparent sourcing, no fillers
- ✓Fully digestible unlike rawhide — breaks down rather than splintering
- ✓USA-sourced beef with published sourcing chain
Cons
- ✗Calorie-dense (~80 cal per 6-inch stick); count toward daily treat budget
- ✗Strong odor for owners (the company sells an odor-free SKU at higher price)