Pet Gear Octagon Pet Pen (36-Inch) vs EliteField 2-Door Soft Pet Playpen

Side by side on specifications and purchase options, so you can judge which suits your dog.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, PawBench earns from qualifying purchases. Prices shown are approximate and subject to change. Always verify current pricing on Amazon before purchasing.

Pet Gear Octagon Pet Pen (36-Inch)
Pet Gear Octagon Pet Pen (36-Inch)
$42.10 ยท โ˜… 4.4 (111)
vs
EliteField 2-Door Soft Pet Playpen
EliteField 2-Door Soft Pet Playpen
$59.99 ยท โ˜… 4.5 (7,610)
73
Sturdiness
75
73
Safety & Escape-Proofing
81
82
Setup & Flexibility
78
86
Value
77
64
Owner Satisfaction
75
Differences only
Spec
Pet Gear Octagon Pet Pen (36-Inch)#1
๐Ÿ’ฐ Best Budget
Pet Gear Octagon Pet Pen (36-Inch)
Owner rating4.4
EliteField 2-Door Soft Pet Playpen#2
โญ Best Value
EliteField 2-Door Soft Pet Playpen
Owner rating4.5
Buy
PawBench Scoremethodology โ†’
Sturdiness
73
Safety & Escape-Proofing
73
Setup & Flexibility
82
Value
86
Owner Satisfaction
64
Sturdiness
75
Safety & Escape-Proofing
81
Setup & Flexibility
78
Value
77
Owner Satisfaction
75
Size36 in octagon42 x 42 x 24 in
Material600D nylon600D fabric + hex mesh
TopRemovable, partly ventedโ€”
Rated ForUp to 60 lb (per listing)โ€”
Doorsโ€”2, zipper locks
Warrantyโ€”2 years (per EliteField)

* Prices are approximate and may vary. Please check the latest price on Amazon.

Pros & cons

Pet Gear Octagon Pet Pen (36-Inch)

Pros

  • โœ“600-denier nylon; folds completely flat (per Pet Gear)
  • โœ“Removable, partly vented top for shade
  • โœ“Water-resistant floor and side storage pockets

Cons

  • โœ—Fabric pens are for supervised use; a chewer or digger can get through
  • โœ—111 ratings on this listing (Classic Pink is the colour in stock)

EliteField 2-Door Soft Pet Playpen

Pros

  • โœ“Two mesh doors, both with zipper locks
  • โœ“Zip-off washable floor mat and top cover
  • โœ“2-year warranty; ground stakes and carry bag included

Cons

  • โœ—Still fabric: not for chewers or unsupervised use
  • โœ—About $20 more than the Pet Gear and Amazon Basics pens

As an Amazon Associate, PawBench earns from qualifying purchases.

โ† View all comparisons