Best Dog Subscription Boxes
Dog subscription boxes have exploded in popularity over the past five years — there are now dozens of services curating monthly deliveries of toys, treats, gear, and supplements. Some are excellent value that surface products you'd never find on your own. Others are a bag of over-priced low-quality treats with a squeaky toy that lasts 20 minutes.
We subscribed to and evaluated 8 popular services over 4 months to find the ones worth recommending. We looked at value (retail value of items vs. subscription cost), product quality, curation relevance to size/preference, and consistency across months.
What to Expect from Dog Subscription Boxes
Most boxes cost $25-$50 per month and claim to deliver $50-$100+ in retail value. In practice:
- The best boxes deliver genuine retail value and surface quality products you'll actually use
- Average boxes pad the "retail value" with products whose "suggested retail" prices are inflated
- The worst boxes deliver mediocre treats and toys you'll find at any dollar store under a "premium" label
Curation quality matters as much as value. A box that correctly remembers your dog's size and preferences is worth more than a random assortment.
Top Dog Subscription Box Picks
Best Overall: BarkBox ($23-$35/month)
BarkBox is the category leader for a reason. Each month delivers 2 toys, 2 full-size bags of treats, and 1 chew — all themed around a cohesive monthly story (recent themes have included "Howl-oween," "Pupsicle Summer," and "Barkuterie Board"). The theming sounds gimmicky but it's actually what makes BarkBox stand out: every product in the box shares a design language and the toys are clearly made with care.
The toys are genuinely high quality — BarkBox designs most of them in-house, and the durability is consistently better than what you'd find at a pet store for the same price. The treat selection sources from small and independent makers, which means you regularly discover products that aren't available in retail stores.
Customization: BarkBox adjusts for dog size (Small, Medium, Large, Extra Large) and has a Super Chewer variant for aggressive chewers that includes heavy rubber and nylon toys instead of plush.
Cost: ~$23/month with annual plan, ~$35 month-to-month. Subscribe at BarkBox.com
Best for: Most dog owners. Best value in the category for toy + treat boxes.
Best for Heavy Chewers: Super Chewer by BarkBox ($30-$45/month)
Super Chewer is BarkBox's variant specifically for power chewers. Instead of plush toys, each box includes 2 durable rubber or nylon toys, 2 bags of treats, and 1-2 chews. The toys are tested for durability by aggressive chewer dogs before being included — they're meaningfully tougher than what you get in the standard box.
If you have a Pit Bull, Rottweiler, Lab, or any dog that destroys plush toys in minutes, the standard BarkBox is wasted money. Super Chewer is specifically what you need.
Cost: ~$30/month with annual plan. Subscribe at SuperChewer.com
Best for Treat Discovery: Yummy Combs Dental Box ($28/month)
Yummy Combs is a specialty subscription focused entirely on dental treats and oral health products. The box includes full-size bags of enzymatic dental chews, tooth-cleaning treats, and dental wipes — a niche but genuinely useful focus for owners trying to maintain their dog's dental health between vet cleanings.
Dental disease affects 80% of dogs over age 3 and is the most common preventable health issue vets see. A subscription that keeps dental treats consistently in the house is a practical health investment.
Best Luxury Box: Bullymake ($39-$49/month)
Bullymake targets power chewers and "bully breeds" with a focus on ultra-durable toys and high-protein treats. Their toys come with a replace or refund guarantee — if a toy is destroyed within the month, they replace it. The box includes 3 toys and 2-3 treat bags, and customers can specify preferred toy materials (rubber, nylon, rope, tennis).
The price premium over BarkBox is real, but the guarantee and higher toy quality justify it for owners whose dogs destroy standard toys quickly.
Cost: ~$39/month with annual plan. Subscribe at Bullymake.com
Best Organic/Natural: The Farmer's Dog Box (varies)
The Farmer's Dog is primarily a fresh food subscription, but their box includes samples of their fresh meals alongside meal prep guides and treats made from their own recipes. For owners considering fresh food, it's the lowest-risk introduction — try before committing to a full subscription.
Not a traditional "toy and treat" box, but worth knowing about if fresh food or natural nutrition is your priority.
Best Value Budget Box: PupBox ($39/month — but includes training content)
PupBox is geared toward puppies and adjusts content for puppy age (8-12 weeks, 3-4 months, etc.), delivering developmentally appropriate toys, treats, and training guides. The training content is genuinely good — written by professional trainers, covering the skills appropriate for that exact developmental stage.
For new puppy owners, the curated developmental approach makes PupBox more valuable than its price suggests. As the puppy ages past 12 months, consider switching to BarkBox.
Month-by-Month Value Comparison
| Box | Monthly Cost | Items | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| BarkBox | $23-$35 | 2 toys, 2 treats, 1 chew | Most owners |
| Super Chewer | $30-$45 | 2 durable toys, 2 treats, 1-2 chews | Power chewers |
| Bullymake | $39-$49 | 3 toys, 2-3 treats | Bully breeds |
| PupBox | $39 | 4-6 items + training guide | Puppy owners |
| Yummy Combs Dental | $28 | Dental treats only | Dental health focus |
How to Maximize Value
- Use the new subscriber discount — most boxes offer 30-50% off the first box. Try it at the discount price before committing.
- Choose annual over monthly — the annual plan discount (typically 30-40%) is substantial.
- Customize preferences aggressively — size, allergies, chew level, preference for plush vs. rubber. The more you tell the service, the better the curation.
- Pause instead of cancel — most services allow pause for travel or tight months. Use this rather than canceling if you're satisfied overall.
Our Verdict
For most dog owners, BarkBox offers the best combination of toy quality, treat variety, and value. For power chewers, Super Chewer is the clear choice. For new puppy owners, PupBox's developmental curation makes it the most useful.
Before subscribing to any box, check if your dog has food allergies or sensitivities — most services accommodate these with advance notice.
For more gear value guidance, see our budget pet gear guide. For specific toy recommendations outside of subscription boxes, see our best dog toys guide.
Note: Links to Amazon may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
Related Reading
- Best Dog Toys 2026 — Individual toy picks tested by real dogs
- Best Dog Health Supplements — Supplements worth buying separately
- Pet Gear Budget Guide — Best value dog products at every price point
