What should I look for when buying Dog Chew Toys?

PawBench · Best Picks

Best Dog Chew Toys

Durable chew toys for aggressive chewers and teething puppies.

Buying Guide

Chew toys serve two purposes: satisfying your dog's natural urge to chew and saving your furniture from destruction. The right chew toy depends entirely on your dog's chew style. "Light chewers" do fine with rubber and nylon. "Power chewers" (pit bulls, labs, shepherds) need heavy-duty rubber or solid nylon — anything less gets shredded in minutes.

Avoid chew toys that are harder than your dog's teeth. A good rule: if you can't make a dent with your fingernail, it's too hard and could crack teeth. This rules out antlers, bones, and some ultra-hard nylons for aggressive chewers. KONG-style natural rubber is the sweet spot — tough enough to last but with enough give to be tooth-safe.

Size matters for safety. A chew toy should be large enough that your dog can't fit the whole thing in their mouth. When toys wear down to a size that could be swallowed, replace them immediately. Budget $10-15 per month for chew toys if you have an aggressive chewer.

Spec	#1💰 Best Budget Kong Classic Dog Toy (Large) 4.7	#2💰 Best Budget Benebone Wishbone Chew (Large) 4.5	#3💰 Best Budget West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Bone 4.4
Buy	🐾 Chewy · $14.99 📦 Amazon · $14.99	🐾 Chewy · $14.49 📦 Amazon · $14.49	🐾 Chewy · $16.95 📦 Amazon · $16.95
Scores	Overall 9.4 Value 9.3 Quality 9.5 Durability 9	Overall 9 Value 9.3 Quality 9.1 Durability 8.6	Overall 8.8 Value 9.2 Quality 8.9 Durability 8.4
Material	Natural red rubber	Nylon with real bacon flavor	Zogoflex (BPA-free, FDA food-safe)
Size	Large (dogs 30-65 lbs)	Large (dogs 30+ lbs)	Large (8.5 inches)
Chew Strength Rating	Power chewers	Moderate to aggressive chewers	Moderate to power chewers
Best For	Stuffing, freezing, solo play	Flavor-motivated chewers	Eco-conscious owners, fetch + chew combo
Weight	8.8 oz	—	—
Country of Origin	—	USA	—
Dishwasher Safe	—	—	Yes

* Prices may vary. Click to see latest pricing at each retailer.

Budget:

Top Pick

Kong Classic Dog Toy (Large)

💰 Best Budget

4.7

The Kong Classic has been the gold standard in chew toys for over four decades, and nothing has come close to dethroning it. Fill it with peanut butter, freeze it overnight, and you get 30 minutes of focused, quiet chewing from even the most restless dog. If you own a dog and don't own a Kong, fix that today.

Compare vs #2 →

Pros

✓Virtually indestructible natural rubber
✓Stuffable and freezable for extended play
✓Unpredictable bounce keeps dogs engaged

Cons

✗Can leave red marks on light-colored floors
✗Extreme power chewers can still tear chunks off

Material

Natural red rubber

Size

Large (dogs 30-65 lbs)

Chew Strength Rating

Power chewers

Best For

Stuffing, freezing, solo play

Weight

8.8 oz

Runner Up

Benebone Wishbone Chew (Large)

💰 Best Budget

4.5

Benebone solved the biggest problem with flavored chews: the taste actually lasts because real bacon is infused throughout, not just coated on the surface. The wishbone shape lets dogs pin it down and gnaw with purpose, which most other chew toys make frustratingly difficult. Just monitor your dog closely — if they're the type to break off and swallow chunks, this isn't the right pick.

Compare vs #3 →

Pros

✓Real bacon flavor baked throughout the entire chew
✓Ergonomic wishbone shape is easy for dogs to hold
✓Made in the USA with food-grade ingredients

Cons

✗Not edible — must be replaced when small pieces break off
✗Aggressive chewers can fracture it into sharp pieces

Material

Nylon with real bacon flavor

Size

Large (dogs 30+ lbs)

Chew Strength Rating

Moderate to aggressive chewers

Best For

Flavor-motivated chewers

Country of Origin

USA

Great Value

West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Bone

💰 Best Budget

4.4

West Paw's Hurley is the chew toy you buy when you care about sustainability without sacrificing durability. The Zogoflex material is genuinely tough, dishwasher safe, and backed by a replacement guarantee that no other brand matches. It's the eco-conscious pick that actually holds up to daily abuse — not just greenwashing slapped on a mediocre product.

Pros

✓100% recyclable and FDA food-safe material
✓Guaranteed against dog damage — free replacements
✓Floats and bounces for versatile play

Cons

✗Higher price than basic chew toys
✗Some dogs lose interest without added flavor

Material

Zogoflex (BPA-free, FDA food-safe)

Size

Large (8.5 inches)

Chew Strength Rating

Moderate to power chewers

Best For

Eco-conscious owners, fetch + chew combo

Dishwasher Safe

Yes

← Back to Dog Toys

Best Dog Chew Toys

Buying Guide

Side-by-Side Comparison

Kong Classic Dog Toy (Large)

Pros

Cons

Benebone Wishbone Chew (Large)

Pros

Cons

West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Bone

Pros

Cons

Related Reading

Best Dog Crates for Anxiety: Calming Options That Actually Work

Bernese Mountain Dog Health & Gear Guide: What Every Owner Needs

Best Dog Food for Small Breeds: Top Picks for Tiny Dogs